Tag Archives: Naomi Oreskes

short links: open data, candian census, and merchants of doubt

1) An Open Data Litmus Test: Is There a Download Button from Off the Map

In order for any data to be open you need to be able to download the data so that you can remix, reuse and share the data. Data and the government agency that supplies it are not transparent if you can’t download the raw data. PDF’s and web services don’t count. They can be useful additions to the raw data, but they are not a replacements.

2)  Idiotically the Canadian government is planning to stop collecting detailed census data.  As the Toronto Globe and Mail explains:

For the first time in 35 years, the census will not feature a detailed, long form that Canadians are obliged to send back to the government.

Users of census information, including myself, are not happy and somewhat puzzled as to why this decision was made.

3) Historians of science Naomi Oreskes and Erik Conway’s new book  Merchants of Doubt: How a Handful of Scientists Obscured the Truth on Issues from Tobacco Smoke to Global Warming, describes how politically connected scientists have operated effective campaigns to skew public opinion towards the denial of well-established scientific knowledge over four decades, now has a website – merchantsofdoubt.org – that links to a bunch of the documents supporting the books arguemnet. I linked to a lecture based on the book earlier this year, and they recently wrote an article based on their book for Yale360 Global Warming Deniers and Their Proven Strategy of Doubt.

Naomi Oreskes on Merchants of Doubt

Historian of science Naomi Oreskes recently gave a talk at Brown University, based on her new book, Merchants of Doubt: How a Handful of Scientists Obscured the Truth on Issues from Tobacco Smoke to Global Warming, about how right wing scientists founded the George Marshall Institute which has become a key hub for successfully spreading fear, uncertainty and doubt about climate change, along with other environmental issues, and how myths about science enable these political strategies to work.  Below is a video of her talk.

Below is a related 2007 talk of her’s from the University of California The American Denial of Global Warming, that provides more details on environmental denial.